At Old Church Creamery, we are committed to the highest quality & experience for you and your family. 

Old Church Creamery is a family-owned business and all of our products are made right here in our Grade A Creamery in Mechanicsville, Virginia. Our milk is sourced from our family farm in Virginia's Shenandoah Valley. The Jersey cows are happy and content as they graze fresh pastures. The milk is pasteurized gently at a low-temperature to maintain the fresh taste and creamline milk that we're known for. We offer Whole Milk, Chocolate Milk, Whole Milk Yogurt, and our signature probiotic beverage, Kefir. 

Jersey cows are known for their incredible butterfat and milk properties. The high butterfat and protein make for exceptionally delicious and noticeably different milk, yogurt, and kefir.  In fact, see the difference in color in the picture above comparing our whole milk (left) with commercial whole milk (right).  We aim to preserve and represent the quality of the milk by limiting and/or avoiding sugar or flavored ingredients.  Learn more about each product we make below (click the picture to see nutrition facts).  

 

Kefir

 Available in quart and pint sizes.

Available in quart and pint sizes.

Whole Milk YOgurt

 Available in quart and New 24oz size.

Available in quart and New 24oz size.


CREAMLINE WHole Milk

 Available in half gallon and pint sizes. No gallon sizes.

Available in half gallon and pint sizes. No gallon sizes.

Chocolate Milk

 Available in pint sizes only.

Available in pint sizes only.

Fayton Farms Artisan Cheeses

 Fayton Farms Artisan Cheeses: 3 different varieties - Trinity, Trinity Reserve, Trinity's way

Fayton Farms Artisan Cheeses: 3 different varieties - Trinity, Trinity Reserve, Trinity's way


BLACKBERRY DRINKABLE YOGURT (DISCONTINUED)

 Due to labor and supplies costs, this item is has been discontinued until further notice.

Due to labor and supplies costs, this item is has been discontinued until further notice.